Portland 
Copwatch - a project of Peace and Justice Works

 

Site Navigation

Home
About us
People's Police Report
Shootings & deaths
Cool links
Other Information
Contact info
Donate
 

 

Racial Profiling:
Chief Kroeker Continues to Discount Statistics,
and other stories

And the beat goes on

Racial profiling figures through June 30 show that Portland Police continue to stop African American motorists at more than twice the rate of white motorists, with the greatest disparity occurring on the city's west side where African Americans were five times more likely to be stopped than whites. In East Precinct, African Americans were 1.6 times more likely to be stopped than whites. These figures are similar to information released in April 2001 (see PPR #24).

The next report will include data collected by motorcycle officers, who are involved in about half of all traffic stops, as well as foot patrol, bicycle, and mounted patrol officers.

Said Chief Kroeker, "I would propose that we keep an open mind about what this data really means" (Oregonian, August 31).


FLASHBACK: "You're left with... questions that are valid for discussion... We need help from professionals to give some analysis on this" ­Chief Kroeker on the first quarter 2001 stats (see PPR #24)


Taken to task in Tigard

Three African American men have filed civil rights lawsuits against the Tigard police department in two years. The latest was Jimmy Brown, a Multnomah County justice department program manager. Brown, who had stopped and gotten out of his car for a cigarette, was approached by Officer William Napieralski. Napieralski said he "saw a car coming...and the car's brake lights were tapped several times...I was suspicious that the driver was DUII" (Oregonian, August 29). When asked to take a sobriety test, Brown "was upset by the insinuation that he was under the influence."

Napieralski claims he called for backup because he feared for his safety. Brown was allowed to drive himself home about two hours after the initial stop. An internal police investigation concluded, "a credible argument could be made to support Brown's sense that the police contact was not professional and was done by police to exert their authority [but] that there was no evidence to support the contention that the contact was racially motivated." The case is set to go to trial in June 2002.

Altered and amended

The Oregon Council of Police Associations (OCPA) was active in Salem during the 2001 legislative session. Among their victories were changes made to HB 2441 (aka, the racial profiling bill). The bill requires law enforcement officers in Oregon to include a driver's race and the disposition of each stop.

OCPA lobbyist Brian DeLashmutt objected to the original measure because it "would have placed the officers in the position of self-incrimination by requiring them to collect the information, then allowing it to be used against them" (Rap Sheet, August 2001). By analogy, such wacky logic would mean that corporations could avoid tracking how many pollutants they dump in the river for fear that doing so might incriminate them.

HB 2441 was tweaked, amended, and reborn as SB 415 which "encourages jurisdictions to collect data on stops and does not allow the use of the information against the individual officer."

In contrast, the Washington state highway patrol is using the racial profiling data it collects "to question and discipline individual troopers whose records suggest racial profiling" (Oregonian, July 1). It seems Oregon has taken a back seat to justice on this issue.


Portland Mercury managing editor Phil Busse once again covered issues of police accountability on November 1, this time proposing that Portland is ripe for a race riot. He quotes one expert, Dr. Ray Winbush of the Race Relations Institute in Nashville, TN, who lists Cincinnati, Miami, New York, and Portland as cities ready for trouble. Busse then points out a number of questionable cases in recent Portland history: The Greek Cusina off-duty police brawl (see PPR #24), the manhandling of grandmother Dora McCrae (see PPR #21), and the shooting of citizen crime-fighter Bruce Browne at a mini-mart (see article in this issue). Unfortunately, Busse also gets many of his facts wrong, including some about Portland's police review board that we pointed out to him months ago (see PPR #23). We encourage the Mercury to (a) keep focusing on issues of racial disparity and police misconduct and (b) hire a fact-checker.


  People's Police Report

December, 2001
Also in PPR #25

City Renews FBI-Police Terror Task Force
  • San Francisco Barred from JTTF
Engineless New Review Board Hires Staff
Police Accountability Campaign Nears End
PIIAC Not Quite Ready to Wrap Up
Police Arrest, Hog-tie Wrong Man
Racial Profiling: Chief Discounts Statistics
Portland Police Bias Shows in Two Shootings
  • Washington County Deputies Kill Distraught Man
"Bean Bag" Report: Less-than-lethal is a Lie
Updates PPR 25
  • Mejía Family Settles with Hospital, Not City
  • Family Dedicates Memorial Garden to Dickie Dow
  • Dignity Village Moves to Official Location
  • Three Cops Cleared of Misconduct in Anti-Camping Case
  • House Party Raid Saga Ends with Plea Bargain
  • County DAs Withhold Evidence from Cop
  • SERT Hazing Investigation "Drags" On
Chief Kroeker Likes Cops, Not Bias Crimes
Quick Flashes PPR 25
  • Pro-Police Parade Permit Process Perpetuated
  • News from Around the Country (Cincinnati, Miami)

Rapping Back #25
 

Portland Copwatch
PO Box 42456
Portland, OR 97242
(503) 236-3065/ Incident Report Line (503) 321-5120
e-mail: copwatch@portlandcopwatch.org

Portland Copwatch is a grassroots, volunteer organization promoting police accountability through citizen action.


People's Police Report #25 Table of Contents
Back to Portland Copwatch home page
Peace and Justice Works home page
Back to top